Markets are holding recent gains ahead of the employment report.
Another day of tight trade supporting the breakout. This was the third-close above 1540 and shows holders are willing to hold and buyers are willing to buy. Volume was average and slightly lower than recent days. A fourth close above 1540 shows sellers are absent and this market wants to continue higher.
Every time the market starts making all-time highs, the academics descend from their ivory towers and warn of irrational exuberance, impending crashes, bubbles, euphoria, and all that jazz. But the thing to remember is these guys are historians, not traders. They call the top, the market rallies another year, and they still proclaim to the world how right they were when the market finally corrects twelve-months from now.
We are the one putting money on the line and theory just doesn’t cut it. Telling us that markets go down after they go up is completely and totally useless. Tell me when they will go up and down and now we have something to act on. Without a doubt the market will pullback 7% or more at some point this year. How do I know that? Because the market always does. That’s the easy part, all the money is made in figuring out exactly when that pullback is going to happen.
While I don’t pay much attention to what these academics and historians are preaching from their soapbox, the fact that they are getting airtime is meaningful. Journalists are not analysts, they simply report what other people tell them. When the market is pessimistic, they interview pessimists and report pessimistic stories. When everyone is in a good mood, they cover positive stories and interview bulls.
When the media tells us these gains are unsustainable, I know that is what traders are telling journalists. The financial press is a great reflection of what the market is thinking. Without a doubt this market will top and that top is coming, I just know the market won’t top when everyone is talking about it. Whether it takes weeks or months of new highs to wring the pessimism from the markets I don’t know, but I do know the crowd and financial press usually get it wrong. When they talk about corrections, we bet on the continuation. I’m not saying it is impossible for the market to correct here, but it is less likely when everyone expects it.
I also want to point out financial history is a critical tool I use when analyzing the market and I don’t mean to demean the views shared by academics, I’m simply pointing out they typically have poor timing. We can actually broadening that statement even further by saying most people have poor timing. If this were easy, everyone would be rich.
Last year the market was buzzing in anticipation of each employment report as the recovery was just taking hold, but recently the market is less obsessed with it. It might be getting to the point where modest gains are taken for granted and only a big deviation will move markets. And to be honest it really doesn’t matter one way or the other because the market reads into these numbers what it wants to see. We don’t trade fundamentals, we trade expectations. If bulls want to buy, they will invent reasons to buy. If bears want to sell they will find excuses to sell.
If we take the view that the actual number is less important than what the market wants to do, we will be fairly constructive on this market because every sign is it wants to continue higher. If we have a disappointing number, we might dip, but expect traders to find a sliver lining in the report and buy the dip. That is what they did with negative GDP and is what they will likely do with a disappointing employment report.
If the expected outcome is the employment report is not a big deal, then the alternate is the market hinges on this report. The only time this is true is when it materially changes people’s views of the future and they adjust their portfolio to reflect this new reality. A negative employment report will not be meaningful for pessimists because they already expect it and adjusted their portfolio ahead of time. To crash the market, the employment report would need to convince bulls to give up and sell. While less likely, it is still a real possibility and why we start any trade with defense first. We always know where our stops are and when the market doesn’t act as expected, we sellout and look for the next opportunity.