Price Trumps Sentiment

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks traded in a tight, five-point range Monday, consolidating Friday’s breakout to new highs. While we spent all of the day in the red, such minor losses are constructive because it shows few owners are taking profits or selling defensively.

Bullish sentiment is ramping up and at the highest levels since December’s top. While rising sentiment gives us pause, 56% bullishness could easily give way to 65% or 70% in coming days. It is important to watch sentiment, but it is only a secondary indicator.

Price is the main driver of trading strategy and so far the price-action is strong. The most impressive thing is how well the market is weathering the storm of bearish headlines. On-again, off-again negotiations between Greece and Europe couldn’t dent this rebound. Neither could a failed truce in Ukraine. And it’s been a while since we had economic numbers exceeded expectations. All of these headlines should have sent us into a 200-point tail-spin, but when the market doesn’t do what it is supposed to, that is a very clear signal it wants to go the other direction. If we don’t selling off on negative headlines, what is going to happen when we finally get some good news?

Source: Stocktwits 2/23/2015

While I remain cautious of this market because of the rising bullishness, this strength cannot be ignored. Right or wrong, stock owners are not interested in selling. Without sellers, supply stays tight and prices continue creeping higher. Until we find something that finally cracks bulls’ resolve, the only direction to trade this market is higher.

Jani

Stalling or Consolidating?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks were unable to break through 2,100 for a fourth day. Should we be worried?

There are two ways to interpret this price-action. If demand dries up above 2,100, that tells us this rebound is running out of steam. The more bullish interpretation is we are consolidating recent gains before making the next leg higher.

How do we know which scenario applies here? Technicians claim all we need is price, but price alone doesn’t give us the answer. We need to dig deeper into the market’s psyche to figure out what traders are thinking and how they are positioned.

We would be stalling if the market was unable to break 2,100 with bullish headlines blowing at our back. When things are as upbeat as they can get, yet the market fails to make further progress, that tells us we ran out of buyers. With headlines screaming Greece, Ukraine, rate hikes, falling oil prices, and slowing global growth, it is a big stretch to claim this rally has a tailwind.

It is far easier to make the argument we are stubbornly holding up in the face of a tidal wave of bad news. Bears are dumbfounded by how “stupid” this market is for not breaking down when there are so many obvious reasons we should be plunging. But here’s the thing, these bearish headlines have been around for weeks. Anyone who fears these stories sold weeks ago to buyers willing to own these risks. Once everyone who is afraid of an event leaves the market, then it can no longer hurt us because there is no one left to sell it. And that is exactly what happened. Greek and European negotiations blew up in a spectacular fashion Monday, yet Tuesday we set record highs. Strength in the face of bad news tells us this market still wants to go higher. Short this market at your peril.

Jani

Why We Should Stop Worrying About Greece

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

End of Day Update:

Stocks ended flat as all eyes were turned toward a meeting between Greece and European finance ministers. While progress was made, they failed to reach an agreement and pushed the final deal making to Monday’s meeting.

Clearly the market should be paying attention, but is it something we need to worry about? It seems every bearish amateur investor with a Twitter account is proclaiming the #Grexit will annihilate our market. They confidently believe they have some cunning insight that everyone else is too stupid to recognize. But do they really?

In the summer of 2008, very few professionals knew what MBS and CDS stood for, let alone the risks they posed to our financial system. Only in the aftermath of the collapse did people finally realize what happened. Now compare that blindside to the Grexit that retail investors have been discussing in coffee shops for nearly five years. Everyone in the market is fixated on each twist and turn in the Greek story, meaning if this thing blows up, it won’t catch anyone by surprise. Some predict this is just another false alarm, but even the optimist is well aware of the risks because this story is moving so slowly it is nearly old enough to enter kindergarten. With so much time to prepare, major institutions long ago hedged their exposure and a Greek default will be as traumatic to our financial system as Y2K was.

And there is another thing, markets tend to blow negative news out of proportion. The herd gets spooked and traders stampede for the exits. But we haven’t seen the fear of the unknown and the herd selling yet. What gives?

While every bearish amateur is waiting for the other shoe to drop, what if it already dropped, only no one heard it? If everyone knows about something and has plenty of time to prepare, doesn’t that mean it is already priced in? Hasn’t everyone who fears the #Grexit had plenty of time to sell? If all these people sold ahead of time, then who is left to sell when it happens? Contrary to popular perception, the market doesn’t need to crash for bearish news to be priced in.

There are a lot of things for us to worry about, but the Grexit is not one of them. The market is not reacting to these headlines, not because it is stupid, but because it is more savvy than the amateur investors predicting its demise.

Jani

If you enjoyed this post, retweets are always appreciated!

To Grexit or not to Grexit

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

The S&P500 rebounded from recent weakness and ended at the highest close of the year. Declining oil prices were no longer an excuse for traders to sell stocks as oil gave up a portion of recent gains.

The headline justification for today’s rally was a softening of the standoff between Greek leadership and the ECB. Greece’s new leaders are discovering there is a difference between making campaign promises and being held accountable for the unintended consequences of those decisions.

While the Greek situation could continue to unravel, anyone who fears a Grexit already sold. Those that are left demonstrated they are mostly indifferent to the whole situation and are just as likely to ignore the next round of headlines out of Europe.

When the market is sitting 1% from all-time highs in spite of the fearful headlines, it shows it doesn’t care about these concerns because they are already priced in. Market strength in the face of fear mongering is a buying opportunity. That doesn’t mean the rally is invincible, only that bears will need to come up with something new and unexpected if they want to break the market.

Technically the market is acting well. We found support near 2,050 and the 50dma, setting the stage for today’s upside move to 2,070. The pain trade is betting against the bears since further upside will force them to cover their shorts.

While I expect higher prices in the near-term, I remain cautious further out. The last few years have been an easy, elevator ride higher, but a recent increase in realized volatility shows the market’s personality is shifting. At this point I’m far more likely to sell a breakout to all-time highs than buy it. But I reserve the right to change my mind as new information comes to light.

Jani

If you enjoyed this post, retweets are always appreciated!

Do We Need to Worry?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks stumbled for a second day on intensifying rhetoric from Greece’s new leadership. That was enough to spook European markets and bring ours down in sympathy. But the low-volume, 0.4% loss was almost sleepy as compared to recent volatility.

While the S&P500 failed to hold 2,050 support, there was little urgency from participants to sell the violation. Owners seem fairly comfortable with these headlines and price-action. That confidence would crumble if losses accelerate, but as long as owners continue holding, we won’t have the supply necessary to pressure prices.

Last week’s rebound relieved bulls, but sentiment remains cautious. AAII and Stocktwits sentiment measures saw a big drop in bullishness last week, no surprise given recent headlines. But stable prices in the face of fear-mongering means most of it is already priced in. Those afraid of these headlines had plenty of time to sell, meaning anyone still holding stocks is demonstrating a willingness to own this risk.

While any number of geopolitical situations could flare-up, stability around 2,050 for a couple more days tells us the market is inclined to continue higher. When the market has every reason to sell off, but it insists on going higher, don’t fight it. On the other hand, if we cannot hold the 50dma Tuesday, we have a date with the 200dma.

Jani

If you enjoyed this post, retweets are always appreciated!

Bullish Signs

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks continued the rebound, adding another 1% and closing just shy of January’s double tops at 2,065. Volume was average, but lower than the last six days of elevated trade.

While the market surged 15-points at the open, from there it was one of the most benign days of the year as we traded inside a five-point channel between 2,055 and 2,060. I cannot remember the last time we saw such laid-back intraday trade. We finally “broke out” to the upside in the final minutes of the day, if you count a two-point move to 2,062 as a breakout.

Just a few days ago I was talking about 120-point intraday swings and now a two-point surge at the close is the best we can do. Amazing how quickly things change. Calm, rational, stable trade is good for the markets, suggesting this is more than a dead-cat bounce.

Sentiment remains in the toilet. Stocktwits’ SPY stream is 55% bearish while the latest AAII survey showed bearishness surging 10% and bullishness plunging 9%. It appears recent volatility and fearful headlines have discouraged a large number of retail investors.

But just when things look the worst is usually when they turn around. This is where the last of the hopeful holdouts call it quits and sell their stock at a discount because they cannot stomach the thought of another downday. But once they finish selling, supply tightens up and we bounce. And so far that is exactly what’s happened.

Everyone who fears falling oil prices, Euro uncertainty, and volatility sold to thick-skinned bargain hunters willing to hold the risk. The current crop of owners demonstrated a willingness to own this uncertainty. That’s why when oil falls or tensions flare up in Europe, the market is indifferent. The new owners don’t care about those issues. Right or wrong, prices remain firm when no one sells.

Friday morning we get employment. While this is usually good for a few minutes of volatility, it’s been years since an employment report changed the direction of the market. The talking heads love to hype it up, but it will be ancient history by lunchtime.

Technically the big milestone is 2,065. We were turned back twice in January at this level and a lot of traders will be watching it. If we break it, expect a wave of breakout buying and short-covering. From there we will have to see how the market behaves before deciding if this bounce has the resilience to continue to all-time highs.

Jani

Does Oil Still Matter?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks slogged through most of the day in the red, taken down by a huge drop in oil prices. A late-day rally shook off the early doldrums, pushing us into the green, but that was short-lived as a last-minute headline out of Europe sent the market tumbling into the close.

As dramatic as that sounds, the day was a fairly benign relatively speaking. The market traded sideways, mostly staying between 2,040 and 2,050. This compares favorably to the massive swings we’ve seen in recent sessions.

With oil down as much as 9%, it was constructive to see the market slip only a fraction of a percent. That shows a big chunk of the oil story is already priced in. Anyone afraid of plunging oil prices sold weeks ago, and is why today’s oil dip didn’t concern current owners much. In fact, it was quite bullish to see the market break into the green toward the end of the day. That is, until the ECB rained on our parade.

Without getting too technical, the ECB decided to play hardball with Greece’s newly elected, anti-austerity leaders. This high-stakes game of chicken roiled markets in the final minutes. But the question we have to ask is if Greece still matters? We’ve been down this road before. Back then numerous financial institutions were vulnerable to a Greek default, but this time it is less of a surprise and the bulk of Greek debt is held by governments. While German taxpayers won’t be happy, at least this time it shouldn’t threaten to seize European banking flows.

But that kind of thinking uses logic, not the market’s strong suit in uncertain times. This afternoon’s sell-first, ask-questions-later later mentality could send prices careening dramatically lower Thursday. But at the same time, many traders who lived through multiple Greek crises could see this as just another Red Herring trying to get them to sell their stocks for a discount. Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me. It will be interesting to see which mindset traders show up with Thursday morning. So far overnight futures are down modestly, suggesting the Greek story is not spiraling out of control.

Technically, the market struggled with 2,050 resistance the last two days. Look for a surge of breakout buying and short-covering if we get through this level. That should push us to 2,060, which will be a far larger test of this young rebound since that is where we stalled multiple times in January. On the downside, be wary of an inability to reclaim the 50dma and 2,050. If the market cannot keep recent gains and slips under 2,020, then we will most like continue sliding through the 200dma.

Jani

Why This Isn’t Done Yet

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks exploded higher for a second day. Some claimed headlines out of Australia, Europe, and the oil market were the catalyst for this rebound, but the market’s stubborn resilience at 2,000 was telling us days ago that it wanted to go higher. When prices refuse to break down on bearish headlines, it doesn’t take much to send us higher.

Volume was well above average as shorts were squeezed when we crossed technical resistance at 2,020 in early trade and broke above the 50dma late in the day. Any short with disciplined stop-losses was sent scrambling by this strength. We closed just a hair under 2,050 and this will be the next meaningful level the market needs to summit if this rebound is to continue. But the bigger test will be the third attempt at 2,060, a level two previous rallies stalled at in January.

Sentiment remains fairly bearish. While today’s rebound softened some of that pessimism, the 70-point rebound has been so swift, few have had the opportunity to buy back in. That means there is still a huge pool of recent sellers that need to get back in if the market keeps going up. Reactive sellers become reactive buyers, and the volatility continues.

An increase in volatility is a common symptom of changes in trend and I remain wary of this market over the medium-term, but as a swing-trader is hard not to exploit this bounce for a quick buck. I’m not sure if we will set new all-time highs, but breaking 2,060 and triggering another round of breakout buying and short-squeezing seems likely.

Jani

Where is the Breakdown?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

This morning stocks continued Friday’s late-day sell off and undercut recent support at 1,990. This was the lowest we’ve been since mid-December and the technical weakness triggered a wave of stop-loss selling. But it didn’t devolve panicked rush of the exits and we quickly bounced off 1,980, ultimately closing higher by a very respectable 1.3%.

Today’s wild, 120-point intraday ride continues the wide and loose trade. While volatility is rarely good for markets, the inability for threatening headlines and dramatic price-action to trigger wider selling leads me to believe we are close to a near-term bottom. The market’s given us plenty of reasons to sell, yet owners and buyers have stubbornly hung on to this 2,000+/- region.

Source: Stocktwits.com 2/2/2015

I remain fairly pessimistic, but when the market isn’t doing what I think it should, then I have to reevaluate. Resisting so many opportunities to breakdown tells us there is more support than most assume. I continue to be wary of the market’s medium-term prospects, but when it doesn’t want to go down, then we cannot fight it. Even if this is just a bull trap that stalls near the 50dma, it is best for shorts to take profits and step aside.

Part of what makes me reconsider my negative outlook is how pessimistic traders have become. Stocktwits’ SPY bullish sentiment dipped under 40%, a fairly reliable buy signal recently. Many of the gurus on TV also expect us to continue sliding. But if the pessimists have already sold and those still holding are hunkered down and prepared to sit through bigger declines, then who is the incremental seller? When we run out of supply, then it doesn’t matter what the headlines are.

Jani

Does This Mean We’re Safe?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks bounced back, reclaiming a big chunk of Wednesday’s losses. Volatility remains insane as today’s 35-point intraday surge nearly matches yesterday’s 40-points intraday slide.

While today’s third bounce off of 1,990 revives bull’s confidence, it is hard to feel good about a market that whips around 2% a day. Boring markets are healthy and bullish, but this market is anything but boring.

We are only three-percent from all-time highs, but this volatility shows uneasiness creeping in. The Wall Street Journal reports intraday price ranges have swelled 50% this year as compared to 2014’s more sedate trade. Yet the VIX remains under its 10-year average of 20, showing lower than typical levels of fear. And not only is the market near all-time highs, we are also trading at premium forward earnings multiples versus historic averages, 17 vs 14.6.

Source: WSJ.com

Record stock prices, increasing realized volatility, low implied volatility, and stretched multiples; makes you wonder if smart money is buying or selling here. Okay, I admit that was a rhetorical question because the answer is obvious.

Stay safe.

Jani

That Hurt

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks took bullish, blowout earnings from AAPL and turned them into a gut wrenching selloff. When the market crumbles on good news, you know we are in trouble. Some blame the weakness on the Fed’s midday policy statement claiming the economy is expanding at a “solid pace” and job gains are strong. Funny the world we live in when great news triggers a 40-point intraday selloff.

But this shouldn’t surprise regular readers of this blog. For a while we’ve noted the weak demand every time this market tried to rebound. The elevated volatility is also a grave concern because it tells us the market’s personality is changing. That doesn’t mean we are headed for a 2008 style collapse, but we shouldn’t automatically expect every dip to be a buying opportunity. We knew this pattern couldn’t last forever and this time the weakness feels different.

Today’s selloff closed above key psychological support at 2,000, but the market closed before the late-day sell off could take us any lower so I’m not sure that qualifies as holding support. There is a lot of pressure on bulls to get this turned around Thursday. If we break under 2,000 support, December lows and the 200dma are the next stop as formerly confident and complacent bulls turn into scared sellers.

While I remain skeptical of this market, I will have to reevaluate my outlook if the market bounces and breaks through overhead resistance at 2,060.

No doubt Thursday will be an interesting and insightful day.

Jani

Failing Support

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks stumbled on a combination of disappointing economic news and weak blue chip earnings. We crashed through technical support at the open, recovering some of those losses by the close, but not enough to push the market back above support.

It is a strange world we live in when markets rally on seemingly devastating news for Euro stability, but then a hodgepodge of obscure economic indicators and company earnings take the market’s legs out. Volatility has become par for the course and nothing should surprise us anymore.

The thing that troubles me is we have seen very little volatility in the market’s steady ascent from the 2011 lows. For a long stretch, we could count all the 1% moves on our fingers. But more recently, a 1% move is benign and more often we are surging and crashing from day-to-day. It really feels like the market’s personality is changing. If that’s the case, it means we are going from steady up trend to something else. Maybe that’s choppy sideways trade. Maybe it’s the long-awaited correction. Or maybe we explode higher in one last surge before collapsing. Only a few percent from all-time highs, it is hard to conclude which of these outcomes is happening, all we can say for sure is this feels different.

Index futures are up after Apple’s blowout earnings, but the market decoupled from Apple a few years ago and the two often trade independently. A big move for Apple doesn’t automatically raise all boats in the S&P500. Outside of a brief pop at the open, the Apple story will become a single stock event and the rest of the market will quickly return to whatever else has been driving it recently.

Technically, if the market cannot reclaim 2,050 by Wednesday’s close, that shows we are running out of buyers and should prepare for a test of the 200dma. This the time for bulls to show they are still in control. If they cannot, lookout below.

Jani

What Grexit?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks bounced back from opening weakness following the Greek elections. While this result significantly increases the chances for a “Grexit”, we’ve been down this road before. Last time selling Greek uncertainty was a mistake and it appears traders don’t want to be fooled a second time. Headlines that triggered a wave of selling a few years ago, barely budged the needle today.

Two mitigating factors are the election’s result was widely expected and most institutions have hedged their exposure to Greek default. So it’s not a surprise the market’s reaction was so muted. Of course the thing to be aware of is the lack of a selloff leaves us vulnerable if the situation devolves and is worse than expected.

But just because we don’t have to worry about Greece doesn’t mean we have nothing to worry about. The market is up nearly 100% from the 2011 lows and anyone betting on this market is fat, dumb, and happy. While the market can always continue higher, it is getting harder and harder to find cynics to convert into believers. Markets top when everything looks the best because that is when everyone has already bought all the stock they can.

Trading near record highs, it is hard to identify the next buying catalyst since there is so little fear. While we could see a temporary surge if we break through recent resistance at 2,060, that momentum will likely only carry us to previous highs near 2,100. After that it is hard to figure out what is going to get those that haven’t bought yet to start. If we run out of demand, that leaves us with two outcomes, an extended trading range, or the larger selloff everyone’s been predicting since 2011.

If we hold 2,050 through Wednesday, then we will test the old highs. Fail and prepare for a swift ride to the 200dma.

Jani

Not Done Yet

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks slipped for a fifth consecutive day as overseas concerns dominated financial headlines. After three years of currency manipulation, Switzerland gave up and let the franc float. It exploded higher, catching many traders and institutions off guard.

While this move won’t have much of an impact on US earnings, it affects the financial system. Traders who have margin calls in one asset class, raise capital by selling other assets, often those showing the biggest gains. That means we could see some liquidation pressure on US equities. But bigger than just margin calls, this also affects sentiment.

We went from all-time highs a few weeks ago, to obsessing over the half-empty side of the glass. Since every dip has been a buying opportunity, many owners are complacent and not worried about headline noise. The market bounced before and they assume it will bounce again. That’s why we haven’t seen huge waves of selling yet. It also means there are a lot of potential sellers still hiding in the market.

Currently overnight futures are down nearly a percent. If this weakness holds to the open, that puts us near December’s lows. Break that and previously confident owners will start getting nervous. Not far below is the 200dma. Undercutting both of these key levels would trigger a large wave of selling and finally form a capitulation bottom. And that is the bullish scenario. Things get ugly if we crash through 1,950 without finding a bottom. That’s when panic selling takes over and we retest October’s lows.

Jani

What Was That?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update: 

Stocks gapped higher at the open, but buyers failed to embrace the surge and we crashed into the red by early afternoon. It is difficult to come up with anything constructive to say about this price-action. The market gave bulls the perfect kick-start to setoff a short-squeeze and trigger another wave of dip-buying. If we were oversold, that is exactly what would have happened…but it didn’t.

The obvious takeaway is this market is not oversold and we are not poised to rebound. That means we still have more downside before this correction is done. While today’s volume was higher, this wasn’t capitulation. We didn’t undercut recent lows and even though the intraday move was more than two-percent, the closing loss was a barely noteworthy quarter-of-a-percent. The only people who noticed the enormity of today’s move were the ones who follow the market tick-by-tick. To everyone else, this was another uneventful day.

The market is searching for direction. While we are several percent off the highs, we are also making a series of higher-lows. This pennant pattern can only last so long before the market has to breakout to either the upside or downside. This morning we stubbed our head on the high side, but we also found afternoon support on the low-end.

For all the reasons I listed in previous posts, it looks like we have more downside ahead of us. Breaking 2,000 will set off a wave of selling that takes us down to the 200dma. Fail to hold that and a retest of October’s lows is in the cards. While this could be a plunge over a few days, it could also be a slow grind lower over several months. We will see what happens in coming days, but it is hard to get excited by anything the market is showing us since logging new highs two weeks ago.

Jani

Down on Good News

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks tumbled, unimpressed with a stronger than expected employment report. Many pundits and talking-heads blamed the weakness on lagging wage growth, but that is a fairly obscure detail to to trump the headline numbers and derail a two-day rebound.

It is worrisome when markets ignore a bullish headline and instead fixate on a minor detail buried in the report. There was more than enough good news to launch us higher if that is the direction the market was poised to go. Since we sold off instead, that tells us the market is not in the mood to go higher and we need to be prepared for further weakness. When good news cannot move us higher, what will happen when we get some legitimate bad news?

Technically, the market slipped back under 2,050 and is resting on the 50dma. Volume was the lowest in five days, showing not a lot of traders joined in todays selling. That can be interpreted two ways. Either owners are not interested in selling and we will bounce soon. Or, few people sold and there is still a mountain of supply waiting to hit the market. Since complacency is the rule these days, I fear the next trigger that turns confident owners into fearful sellers.

Jani

Sentiment, Sentiment, Sentiment

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks exploded higher as the S&P500 retook the 50dma and 2,050 technical level. While the price move was impressive, a similar surge in volume was conspicuously absent. That tells us the rise was more due to a reluctance of owners to sell than a huge wave of buying.

Sentiment’s been swinging just as wildly as price. Stocktwit’s SPY sentiment went from 68% bullish in late December to 38% earlier this week. Along with price, it bounced back decisively to 50% in recent days. AAII investor sentiment has been on an equally volatile ride, up 10% last week and then down 10% this week. The lag in the AAII poll means most of the responses came before Wednesday and Thursday’s impressive gains. If the survey was real-time, I’d expect a similar resurgence in bullishness as we saw on Stocktwits.

Another interesting nugget from AAII is while sentiment is down, equity allocations in December haven’t been this high since 2007. It appears individual investors haven’t owned this much stock since the top of the last bull market. Contrarian or not, that should give anyone pause.

Friday morning we get monthly employment, but few are worried about it. That means a decent result is already priced in and we shouldn’t expect big gains due to a strong report. Unfortunately the opposite is not true. The complacency about employment means we are vulnerable to the downside if the market is blindsided by anything unexpected.

Personally I expect another respectable employment number to follow the equally impressive US GDP we’ve seen. In the United States, everything looks great and we have little to be concerned about. But that is exactly what makes me nervous. Bull markets run out of gas on good news, not fear and anxiety.

Between the bullish equity allocations, general sense of wellbeing, and increasing volatility, that is enough to make this buy-the-dip guy think twice about buying this dip. This time feel different. While we could easily make new highs in coming days, it just doesn’t feel like the risk/reward is on the dip-buyers side anymore.

Jani

Can We Buy the Dip Yet?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks rebounded and a sigh of relief spread across the market as another crisis was averted. At least that was the initial reaction to Wednesday’s bounce off of 2,000. If this was last year, then we’d have a green-light to buy the dip with reckless abandon. But that was back when pessimism ruled and underweight fund managers were forced to chase a market that was quickly leaving them behind. Can we say the same conditions exist at the start of 2015?

The change in calendar gives fund managers three-months of breathing room before they are required to report positions and performance to their customers. There is far less pressure for cautious managers to chase since they now have time on their side. As for pessimism, it is hard to get the market to worry about anything since investors have a ready-made excuse for every concern. This is a dramatic reversal from the days when an economic boogeyman was hiding around every corner (Cyprus, Taper, etc).

Every rally ends and so will this one, but what we really want to know is if this is that time. Dip-buying has become so routine that we will easily coast back up to the 50dma and 2,050 region in coming days. What happens next holds the key to where this market is headed. If we smash through 2,050, then the Teflon rally continues and we have nothing to worry about. If we struggle with 2,050, then it is time to get defensive, very defensive.

I’ve been behind this rally for years, but increasing volatility makes this time feel different. I want to see this run continue, but failing to make new highs will tell us the trend is changing.

Jani

Can Both Bulls and Bears Be Right?

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Another brutal day for the market, this time slipping under prior support at 2,000. The saving grace is we reclaimed this technical level by the close, even if just barely. Volume was higher than yesterday and well above average. No doubt the continued weakness and violation of a widely followed technical level triggered a wave of stop-loss orders, causing this surge in volume.

Timeframe and timing are everything in the market. In a situation like this, both bull and bear can be right. A nimble dip-buyer can make a quick buck when this selloff bounces on Wednesday or Thursday. But the bear could also be right when the rebound fizzles and the selloff continues next week.

Sentiment on Stocktwits SPY boards has been all over the place. Last week it was oozing with 68% bullishness, but a few short days later it flipped on its head with 61% bears boasting about the imminent collapse. We need to remember this is primarily a measure of day-trader sentiment. While a very active group, they are small and cannot sustain directional moves without the support of big money. This Stocktwits sentiment skew likely means we are getting close to near-term bounce, but we need to widen our lens if we want to figure out what happens next. That means looking at investors with a longer time horizon.

Source: Stocktwits 1/6/2015

There have been countless 2015 predictions circulating the financial press and the vast majority of pundits and big money managers expect this to be another good year. But the thing to remember is people naturally talk their book. If they are bullish on the market, then they are already fully invested. Where we run into trouble is when everyone is bullish, that means few are left to buy the market and keep pushing it higher.

We’ve gotten used to sharp selloffs followed by equally fast rebounds. If the market finds a floor Wednesday or Thursday, expect the dip-buyers to rush in and send us back to the 50dma and 2,050. But since this trade is getting a tad too obvious, be prepared for the relief to be temporary. The market is split in two, diametrically opposing camps, bulls expecting us to continue marching higher and bears predicting a devastating collapse. The third, and most widely overlooked option is a slow grind lower with countless head fakes along the way to zing and humiliate overly aggressive bulls and bears.

Jani

This Feels Different

By Jani Ziedins | End of Day Analysis

S&P500 daily at end of day

End of Day Update:

Stocks tanked on the first real trading day of 2015, continuing the selloff that started in the final sessions of 2014. Volume was above average and this was a meaningful move, unlike the low-volume, holiday fluff we’ve seen recently. The question is if this is just another routine, buyable dip like all the others, or the start of something different?

Volatility often picks up during changes in trend. This is where one side is losing control and the other is getting stronger. For the first time in a while, both forces are on equal footing. The battle gets scrappier and price moves are more dramatic. Big drops followed by big rebounds. And more plunges and bounces.

For the last three-years I’ve been a buy-the-dip guy, but this one feels different. Back then the market sold off as traders feared the worst around every corner. But bull markets feed on this fear. Low expectations make it easy for a market to rally. But here we find ourselves without a worry. The rest of the world has been melting down over the last six-months, but US Blue Chips have been immune to whatever ales the rest of the world. No doubt they became a safe harbor in a turbulent world, but how much longer can that last? If US markets are still pricing in continued strength, it is harder to exceed those expectations and all too easy to miss the mark. That doesn’t give us a favorable risk/reward.

Every market tops when it runs into a dip that doesn’t bounce to new highs. The big tell for us is what happens next. Today we sliced through the 50dma on accelerating volume. No doubt we took out technical stop-losses and triggered a wave of defensive selling. Buy-the-dip has become such a routine trade that it shouldn’t surprise anyone to see the market bounce in the next day or two. But will there be enough buying behind that rebound to send us back to new highs? Or will the move stall and we stumble into another round of liquidations?

It feels different this time and it is hard to get excited about buying the dip. The confirmation will be a string of lower-highs and lower-lows. If that is the case, forget about the 200dma, October’s 1,820 lows are at risk. While everyone fears a huge selloff over a couple of days, the real damage comes from a six-month grind lower.

Jani